Here is Dr Giuliano's response to my e mail. Clear as mud to me.
David,
There are sever different polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers that are used to test for
HPV. The ideal assay is dependent on the type of specimen. For example, in our studies of female and males where we obtain freshly collected exfoliated cell samples of the cervix, penile epithelium, or oral gargle we use Roche�s assay � Linear Array, which allows us to simultaneously detect 37 different
HPV types. When we are working with tumor specimens we prefer to use the LiPa assay which uses a much smaller PCR primer that gives much higher sensitivity in tumor specimens � this detects 27
HPV types simultaneously. We are using the LiPa assay for our funded lung cancer study. We have another assay which is used to quantify viral load. This assay uses an
HPV type specific primer and is also very sensitive. Currently we quantify viral load from specimens that are
HPV 6, 11, 16, and 18 positive. None of the above assays are licensed for use in clinical practice.
In the hospital laboratory I understand that p16 is used as an assay as it strongly correlates with
HPV status.
Hope this helps and hope to see you soon.
Anna
Anna R. Giuliano, PhD
Chair, Department of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics
H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center and Research Institute