There is some truth in everything. I used the PEG while maintaining swallowing through almost 100 OZ of water daily and a milkshake every night. The PEG was my nutrition and used for vegetable juices, baby foods, Naked Juice, and Jevity. Had I not had the flu or battled a severe tongue ulcer I would have lost maybe 7 to 10 pounds. You don't appreciate it until you need it. My SLT group never had to force any swallowing exercises on me and I could not wait to get the PEG removed when I could maintain my weight for 10 straight days without using it. Never lost the capability.