Lyn
Karen and I basically agree to disagree on this
HPV Erbitux issue but her last post overstates her position IMO. While not a clinical trial, my comments are based on a study of 49 patients with
Erbitux and
HPV. It is evidence, just not conclusive. But there is no conclusive evidence that
Erbitux does work with
HPV either. I can't let an overbroad statement about
Erbitux go uncontested on the forum.
We discussed it at length (5 pages) in this thread
HPV & Erbitux As I stated in that thread, the Bonner trial proves nothing about
HPV &
Erbitux. While you can extrapolate and make a good guess, it is actually less evidence than the 49 patient study IMO since that study did not track
HPV status as Karen admits. Plus I actually had
Erbitux.
No need to repeat all the points in that thread as we all said our piece.
I hope the
Erbitux works for you. I am about to start my third time of chemo and my MO won't even consider
Erbitux for my treatment this time either. Since you were also a smoker, your cancer may be more resistant than normal. Here is a study suggesting that but it only had 30 patients
EGFR P-GP Smoking Charm