OK so now I have Googled the guy, and he is an infectious disease doc at one of the best cancer centers which is close, but not an epidemiologist. So he's got the letters after his name.

But for sure he has not read the most current stuff, and the logic which I have heard HPV experts speak to about its transfer at so many conferences, is too obvious. I can't believe that someone with his credentials missed the idea. (Or disagrees with it) We'll see what he says when he returns (I hope) my email I just sent him. He may have knowledge that I haven't heard or read, and certainly he has clinical experience that is leading his thought process.