Hi Apappala, and welcome -- I'm so sorry you and your husband are up against this.   Some people find it invaluable to seek a 2nd opinion, so you can have the benefit of weighing two sets of medical opinions on your best course of action.  
  I'm new to all this too, but I think PET scans can only detect cancer that's already established.   Radiation tries to eradicate cellular traces of cancer before they gain a toehold.  
  There are definitely people who are treated with surgery only, you can find a few here by looking at folks' signature lines.   I would guess that many more have moved on and don't participate regularly in the forum, simply because they have fewer treatment issues and side effects to deal with.
  I think it's fantastic that your husband has been treated so promptly and before lymph node spread, that's very much in your favor.
 
         
53 T3N2aM0  HPV+ 5/26/13 discovered painless superball-sized lymph node in neck 6/26/13 DX SCC R palatine tonsil 7/16/13 TORS tonsillectomy & selective ND, mets to 2 nodes 9/3/13 Cisplatin and rads begin, tolerated 1.5 of 3 planned chemo doses 10/16/13 Treatment ends Dec 13  Ulcer appears at surgery site Jan 17  Biopsy -- no cancer! Feb 17 CT/PET Scan lights up tonsil bed & nasal cavity, docs say probably inflammation, don't panic, rescan when ulcer subsides 
  |