Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#149097 05-04-2012 01:13 PM
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,082
Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts)
OP Offline
Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts)

Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,082
I missed this article when it came out in July 2011 in the Atlantic magazine, but Utne Reader picked it for its May 2012 issue. Here is the link to the complete article
Triumph of New Age Medicine It's thought provoking although my feelings still are more in line with Dr Salzberg - the first quote below. Yet this article acknowledges all that and basically says: So what? emphasis added in second quote
[quote]Nonetheless, says Salzberg, the bottom line is that studies clearly show alternative medicine simply doesn�t work. And at first glance, that contention seems nearly incontrovertible. The scientific literature is replete with careful studies that show, again and again, that virtually all of the core treatments plied by alternative practitioners, including homeopathy, acupuncture, chiropractic, and others, help patients no more than do �sham� treatments designed to fool patients into thinking they�re getting the treatment when they�re really not. (Even acupuncture can be faked, by tapping the skin in random places with a metal tube; reliably, these taps produce treatment results identical to those of the needles themselves.) �Acupuncture is just a 3,000-year-old relative of bloodletting,� Salzberg told me. [/quote]

[quote]Studies have also shown that alternative treatments such as acupuncture tend to produce a larger placebo effect than merely handing out sugar pills, presumably because alternative treatments involve more ritual, and thus further raise patients� expectations. In other words, alternative practitioners tend to do a better job at �selling� the placebo effect.

One might argue that a system of care that merely delivers a powerful, relatively safe placebo for many conditions�without side effects�has at least something to commend it, when compared with the system of care we actually have today. Yet to focus on alternative medicine�s placebo effect ignores what may be its largest benefit�its adherence to a �healing� model of patient care.

Randomized controlled trials, the medical world�s gold standard for assessing the efficacy of treatments, cannot really test for this effect. Such studies are perfect for testing pills and other physically administered treatments that either have a direct physical benefit or don�t. (In its simplest form, a controlled study randomly assigns patients to receive either a drug or the equivalent of a sugar pill. If the real thing doesn�t bring on more improvement than the placebo does, the drug is a washout.) But what is it that ought to be tested in a study of alternative medicine? To date, the focus has mostly been on testing the physical remedies by themselves�divorced from any other portion of a typical alternative-care visit�with studies clearly showing that the exact emplacement of needles or the undetectable presence of special ingredients in homeopathic water isn�t really having any significant physical effect on the patient.
[/quote]
Fun reading I wanted to share. Plus there was no nonsense in this article about not getting Radiation and Chemotherapy and Surgery for cancer. I wish the Placebo effect worked on Cancer but we all know it does not.
Charm

Last edited by Charm2017; 05-04-2012 01:15 PM. Reason: typos

65 yr Old Frack
Stage IV BOT T3N2M0 HPV 16+
2007:72GY IMRT(40) 8 ERBITUX No PEG
2008:CANCER BACK Salvage Surgery
25GY-CyberKnife(5) 3 Carboplatin
Apaghia /G button
2012: CANCER BACK -left tonsilar fossa
40GY-CyberKnife(5) 3 Carboplatin

Passed away 4-29-13
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 638
klo Offline
"OCF Down Under"
"Above & Beyond" Member (500+ posts)
Offline
"OCF Down Under"
"Above & Beyond" Member (500+ posts)

Joined: May 2010
Posts: 638
Whilst alternative therapies are dangerous if used in place of proven treatment and do not cure cancer, at least you die hoping


Karen
Love of Life to Alex T4N2M0 SCC Tonsil, BOT, R lymph nodes
Dx March 2010 51yrs. Unresectable. HPV+ve
Tx Chemo x 3+1 cycles(cisplatin,docetaxel,5FU)- complete May 31
Chemoradiation (IMRTx35 + weekly cisplatin)
Finish Aug 27
Return to work 2 years on
3 years out Aug 27 2013 NED smile
Still underweight

Link Copied to Clipboard
Top Posters
ChristineB 10,507
davidcpa 8,311
Cheryld 5,260
EzJim 5,260
Brian Hill 4,912
Newest Members
Jina, VintageMel, rahul320, Sean916, Megm37
13,103 Registered Users
Forum Statistics
Forums23
Topics18,166
Posts196,921
Members13,103
Most Online458
Jan 16th, 2020
OCF Awards

Great Nonprofit OCF 2023 Charity Navigator OCF Guidestar Charity OCF

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5