| Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 Contributing Member (25+ posts) | OP Contributing Member (25+ posts) Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 | I have a question that may spark some debate but I am very interested in the opinion of others. If you look at my signature, I am wondering if you would go with a more conservative doctor or aggresive doctor. It seems to me, some people with the same diagnosis as me, have undergone a neck dissection with the removal of nodes. My doctor discussed not having that done at this time. My SCC was found laterally on my tongue. After speaking with my doctor today he described it as "superficial". Invasion was present: depth <0.1 cm. I would like to hear other opinions. The people who are T1 SCC, and had a neck dissection/nodes removed, was yours more invasive than mine?
Thanks for taking the time to reply.
Yvonne
Age 35 Superficial SCC lateral tongue HPV(-), nonsmoker Right lateral tongue resection 1/17/11 w/ Alloderm Graft Proud mother of 2 Enjoy walking/aerobic kickboxing Pittsburgh Steelers Fan! (#86)
| | | | Joined: Apr 2005 Posts: 2,219 Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) | Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) Joined: Apr 2005 Posts: 2,219 | Different surgeons follow different protocols. there is no standard treatment. If you look at my signature you will see that I had a partial glossectomy and 30 nodes removed. That was suggested by my surgeon and I was more than willing to go along with his reasoning for doing it.
There are many members that would disagree with that treatment option, but I am almost 6 years out and am very comfortable having had the neck dissection.
A debate MAY follow!!!!
Jerry
Retired Dentist, 59 years old at diagnosis. SCC of the left lateral border of the tongue (Stage I). Partial glossectomy and 30 nodes removed, 4/6/05. Nodes all clear. No chemo no radiation 18 year survivor.
"Whatever doesn't kill me, makes me stronger"
| | | | Joined: Sep 2006 Posts: 8,311 Senior Patient Advocate Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) | Senior Patient Advocate Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) Joined: Sep 2006 Posts: 8,311 | HPV- go with Mr Aggressive.
David
Age 58 at Dx, HPV16+ SCC, Stage IV BOT+2 nodes, non smoker, casual drinker, exercise nut, Cisplatin x 3 & concurrent IMRT x 35,(70 Gy), no surgery, no Peg, Tx at Moffitt over Aug 06. Jun 07, back to riding my bike 100 miles a wk. Now doing 12 Spin classes and 60 outdoor miles per wk. Nov 13 completed Hilly Century ride for Cancer, 104 miles, 1st Place in my age group. Apr 2014 & 15, Spun for 9 straight hrs to raise $$ for YMCA's Livestrong Program. Certified Spin Instructor Jun 2014.
| | | | Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 Contributing Member (25+ posts) | OP Contributing Member (25+ posts) Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 | David, It is HPV negative. I wasn't sure if you were thinking it was HPV +. HPV negative, would you go with aggresive? Thanks, Yvonne
Age 35 Superficial SCC lateral tongue HPV(-), nonsmoker Right lateral tongue resection 1/17/11 w/ Alloderm Graft Proud mother of 2 Enjoy walking/aerobic kickboxing Pittsburgh Steelers Fan! (#86)
| | | | Joined: Dec 2008 Posts: 1,004 Patient Advocate (1000+ posts) | Patient Advocate (1000+ posts) Joined: Dec 2008 Posts: 1,004 | Yvonne,
Mine was also T1 SCC. I saw a top doc at Penn (excellent hospital in Philly) went for a 2nd opinion with the top doc at Sloan Kettering (same doc that treated Michael Douglas) and my doc that I actually see at Fox Chase and they all said the same thing. That the cancer should be treated surgially only with a partial glossectomy (4 actually) but it was only cancer once in 2007. All the others were a precaution because I had some white spots..it was always severe dyaplasia.
I think in order for you to feel at peace with your decision, you should at least go for a 2nd opinion. As you can see I had 3 from some very good doctors and that is why I can rest at night.
Suzanne *********** T1 SCC on right side of tongue Age 31...27 when diagnosed 4 partial glossectomies No chemo or radiation Biopsy on 2/2/10-Clear Surgery needed again...no later than April 2011 Loving life and just became a mother on 11/25/10 It's not what we CAN'T do..it's what we CAN do:)
| | | | Joined: May 2008 Posts: 551 "Above & Beyond" Member (500+ posts) | "Above & Beyond" Member (500+ posts) Joined: May 2008 Posts: 551 | Yvonne, I went into surgery knowing that I had one 'involved' lymph node and came out of it with three. The difference not only changed my staging, it also changed my follow up treatment protocol to a more aggressive route - Erbitux added and additional radiation. I do have numbness on that side, all the way up to my ear, a large scar and some muscle tightness, but I'm still here and doing well. I think that's a pretty good outcome. - Margaret
Stage IV SCC lt lateral tongue, surgery 5/19/08 (partial gloss/upper neck dissection left side/radial free flap reconstruction) IMRT w/weekly Cisplatin & Erbitux 6/30/08, PEG 1 6/12/08 - out 7/14 (in abdominal wall, not stomach), PEG 2 7/23/08 - out 11/20/08, Tx done 8/18/08 Second SCC tumor, Stage 1, rt mobile tongue, removed 10/18/2016, right neck dissection 12/9/2016 Third SCC tumor, diagnosed, 4/19/2108, rt submandibular mass, HPV-, IMRT w/ weekly Cisplatin, 5/9 - 6/25/2018, PEG 3 5/31/2018
| | | | Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 Contributing Member (25+ posts) | OP Contributing Member (25+ posts) Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 | Thanks you everyone. I just got off the phone with one of the doctors and had all my questions answered. I am very happy to say, but feel bad for others who are going through much worse, that the tissue showed very superficial (microscopic) amount of SCC - not invading the tissue.
Age 35 Superficial SCC lateral tongue HPV(-), nonsmoker Right lateral tongue resection 1/17/11 w/ Alloderm Graft Proud mother of 2 Enjoy walking/aerobic kickboxing Pittsburgh Steelers Fan! (#86)
| | | | Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 291 Gold Member (200+ posts) | Gold Member (200+ posts) Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 291 | Yvonne, I was diagnosed in Sept with superficially invasive scc of ventral tongue, 1 mm deep, if that. Very small, not supposed to do anything. It did. I think it depends upon the histology as well. Mine was moderately well differentiated, so not terrible, but apparently some wilder cells got away.
You are probably ok. My doctor at MD Anderson said he had never seen a small tongue lesion such as mine metastasize, and he had seen lots of cases. So that is why he wanted me to go through radiation. The lymph node was also small, but apparently with some microscopic EC extension, so the chemo got added. The surgeon thought he had gotten everything but they are all cautious here.
Don't mean to upset you or muddy the water, but there it is. Anne
SCC tongue 9/2010, excised w/clear margins:8 X 4 mm, 1 mm deep Neck Met, 10/2010, 1 cm lymph node; 12/21/'10: Neck Diss 30 nodes, 29 clear, micro ECE node, part tongue gloss, no residual scc IMRT & 6 cisplatin 1/20/11-2/28/11 at MDA GIST tumor sarcoma, removed 9/2011, no chemo needed Clear on both counts as of Fall, 2021
| | | | Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 Contributing Member (25+ posts) | OP Contributing Member (25+ posts) Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 25 | Thanks, Anne. You didn't upset me at all. I'm always happy to hear everyone's story.
Age 35 Superficial SCC lateral tongue HPV(-), nonsmoker Right lateral tongue resection 1/17/11 w/ Alloderm Graft Proud mother of 2 Enjoy walking/aerobic kickboxing Pittsburgh Steelers Fan! (#86)
| | | | Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 5,260 Likes: 3 "OCF Canuck" Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) | "OCF Canuck" Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 5,260 Likes: 3 | Forgive me. Call me crazy but I think aggressive is the way to go. Everyone is an individual. Everyone's body responds differently. And while most doctors are pretty accurate when it comes to making their decisions, they aren't 100 percent. There is always that one case that they think "won't" or "shouldn't" but does... Cancer is cancer. Go after it with both barrels blazing. That way in the end... you don't find yourself saying... "I should have..."
As you can see from my sig. I too have a SCC lesion on my tongue. It is a fair size, stage 2 though no metastacies was shown three weeks ago during my MRI. I am still having a hemiglossectomy R/T size - but also the neck dissction done, and if they tell me I will need radiation I will do that too.
Cancer is not something to mess around with. If the means to fight it is at your disposal, then do whatever you have to to make sure it's gone. Best of luck.
Cheryl : Irritation - 2004 BX: 6/2008 : Inflam. BX: 12/10, DX: 12/10 : SCC - LS tongue well dif. T2N1M0. 2/11 hemigloss + recon. : PND - 40 nodes - 39 clear. 3/11 - 5/11 IMRT 33 + cis x2, PEG 3/28/11 - 5/19/11 3 head, 2 chest scans - clear(fingers crossed) HPV-, No smoke, drink, or drugs, Vegan
| | | | Joined: Mar 2008 Posts: 3,082 Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) | Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) Joined: Mar 2008 Posts: 3,082 | Yvonne
Everybody has different takes on neck dissections. It's not really a debate as many OCF posters are content to have neck dissections that end up showing it didn't need to be done at all. They feel better knowing for sure there was no cancer in those lymph nodes. I am the resident contrarian here on OCF so even though I was Stage IV I chose not to have a neck dissection since I was comfortable that the radiation & chemocare of the lymph nodes involved. My ENT surgeon actually supported my decision although both the RO and MO urged me to get neck dissection. But the thought of having unnecessary surgery with major permanent effects dissuaded me. When the cancer came back and I was having major salvage surgery, the neck dissection surgery was just a small part of it so I agreed. The pathology reports showed no cancer in the lymph nodes, and just necrotic tissues. So my ENT surgeon and my decision to forego a neck dissection turned out to be correct. Lots of people simply are not comfortable without taking every possible step, whether absolutely medically "necessary". It's important to work with your doctors and do what works for you. Best wishes Charm 65 yr Old Frack Stage IV BOT T3N2M0 HPV 16+ 2007:72GY IMRT(40) 8 ERBITUX No PEG 2008:CANCER BACK Salvage Surgery 25GY-CyberKnife(5) 3 Carboplatin Apaghia /G button 2012: CANCER BACK -left tonsilar fossa 40GY-CyberKnife(5) 3 Carboplatin Passed away 4-29-13
| | | | Joined: Nov 2009 Posts: 493 Platinum Member (300+ posts) | Platinum Member (300+ posts) Joined: Nov 2009 Posts: 493 | Yvonne, I had a neck dissection, and chemo and radiation. I don't regret it at all. I did,however, have quite a bit of lymph node involvement. My ENT said that we would "throw the book at" the cancer, and I agreed. But, of course, everybody is different. (I was also HPV negative.)
Female, nonsmoker, 70, diag. 5/09 after tongue biopsy: stage IV. Left hemi-gloss. and left selec. neck disec. 30 lymph nodes removed May 20. Over 7 weeks daily rads. with three chemo. PEG removed 12/4/09 Am eating mostly soft foods. Back to work 11/09 Retired 4/1/11. 7 clear scans! Port out 9/11. 2/13. It's back: base of tongue, very invasive surgery involving lifestyle changes. 2/14: Now speaking w/Passey-Muir valve. Considering a swallow study. Grateful to be alive.
| | | | Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 5,260 Likes: 3 "OCF Canuck" Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) | "OCF Canuck" Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 5,260 Likes: 3 | Zengalib - glad to hear you are doing so well that's terrific. Cancer is scary - and insidious - I would much rather take more with no need than less and miss some - I too am HPV neg. And I agreed with your doctor the best defense is a good offense. May many more clear scans come your way!
Cheryl : Irritation - 2004 BX: 6/2008 : Inflam. BX: 12/10, DX: 12/10 : SCC - LS tongue well dif. T2N1M0. 2/11 hemigloss + recon. : PND - 40 nodes - 39 clear. 3/11 - 5/11 IMRT 33 + cis x2, PEG 3/28/11 - 5/19/11 3 head, 2 chest scans - clear(fingers crossed) HPV-, No smoke, drink, or drugs, Vegan
| | | | Joined: Sep 2006 Posts: 8,311 Senior Patient Advocate Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) | Senior Patient Advocate Patient Advocate (old timer, 2000 posts) Joined: Sep 2006 Posts: 8,311 | I put HPV (-) which to me means negative. Sorry I should have made that clearer. So I would opt for Mr Aggressive.
David
Age 58 at Dx, HPV16+ SCC, Stage IV BOT+2 nodes, non smoker, casual drinker, exercise nut, Cisplatin x 3 & concurrent IMRT x 35,(70 Gy), no surgery, no Peg, Tx at Moffitt over Aug 06. Jun 07, back to riding my bike 100 miles a wk. Now doing 12 Spin classes and 60 outdoor miles per wk. Nov 13 completed Hilly Century ride for Cancer, 104 miles, 1st Place in my age group. Apr 2014 & 15, Spun for 9 straight hrs to raise $$ for YMCA's Livestrong Program. Certified Spin Instructor Jun 2014.
| | | | Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 62 Supporting Member (50+ posts) | Supporting Member (50+ posts) Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 62 | Interesting all the different approaches. I tend to think aggressive is best however in my case because I'm stage 1 and a PET scan came back clear, no neck dissection was deemed necessary. I also will not require radiation as I've been told that radiation isn't effective on dysplasia and all the SCC was removed in initial biopsy.
I'm looking forward to reading the pathology report from this weeks partial right lateral gloss with alloderm graft and resection of floor on the right side.
Catherine, SCC floor of mouth DX 2010,unclear margins, PET scan clear, no chemo or rad,biopsy in 9/2010, 2nd excision 10/2010 didn't get all carcinoma in situ; partial gloss & excis. right floor 2/2/2011 margins clear. Part.gloss-10/5/2011 sev dys clean marg. HPV neg. Don't smoke or drink. SCC floor of mouth left side 4/2016. Dysp excis. rt palate 7/2017 Part gloss sev dys lat marg 2/2019 Part gloss free flap rt neck disc 5/2020 Part gloss bilat neck disc 7/2020 33 rad 3 cis.
| | | | Joined: Nov 2009 Posts: 493 Platinum Member (300+ posts) | Platinum Member (300+ posts) Joined: Nov 2009 Posts: 493 | I agree that the different approaches are all very interesting. So far, my docs' approaches have been right on (for me). I am so glad to have this wonderful forum to come to. I wish that I had known about it when I was first diagnosed. My treatments were pretty rough, but hopefully, they did the trick.
Female, nonsmoker, 70, diag. 5/09 after tongue biopsy: stage IV. Left hemi-gloss. and left selec. neck disec. 30 lymph nodes removed May 20. Over 7 weeks daily rads. with three chemo. PEG removed 12/4/09 Am eating mostly soft foods. Back to work 11/09 Retired 4/1/11. 7 clear scans! Port out 9/11. 2/13. It's back: base of tongue, very invasive surgery involving lifestyle changes. 2/14: Now speaking w/Passey-Muir valve. Considering a swallow study. Grateful to be alive.
| | | | Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 99 Supporting Member (50+ posts) | Supporting Member (50+ posts) Joined: Dec 2010 Posts: 99 | For our 1st round with this cancer the recommendation was no chemo/rad as they got clear margins and only one lymph node was involved, said they could tell the cancer had not left the node. Cancer Bd. said odds were in our favor that it was totally gone.
11 months later Emmett started having issues and it took 4 months to get D as a reoccurance. The 4 months of the tumor(s) growning was the problem in my opinion. So bottom line the only thing we would have done differently was to be more aggresive with Drs. when we experienced symthoms of reoccurance. Since we didn't have the RD/Chemo the 1st time we could be more agressive with treatment this round. Then there are well meaning people who tell us if we had the treatment the 1st time it may never have come back. Bottom line is it a crap shot! Just have to make the most educated one you can and then pray for the best.
CG 2 Emmett,7/09 DX SCC rt tongue. T2N1M0, 1 node, marg neg.4/10 PET/CT clear, 9/10 C back. 10/10 Rad hemi, 2 tmrs mod diff. resec flr of mth. Flap 4 nodes/w/ext cap. 11/10 Peg, CX3 HD, 30 rad. 1/31 & 3/21 6/11/11 - PET/CT "activity" 9/11-all Clear. 12/11 peg out. 2/15 still all clear! 9/14 Prostate cancer treated with pencil beam proton therapy, best radiation experience. Keep it in mind as a treatment option for all tumors that can be seen including head and neck.
| | | | Joined: Sep 2009 Posts: 96 Supporting Member (50+ posts) | Supporting Member (50+ posts) Joined: Sep 2009 Posts: 96 | I am kind of along the same lines with Karen. My doctor never expected mine to come back at all and everything was going good with clear CT's but shortly after the two years mark - it's baaaack. I actually found the spot just having the doctor check on something that was bothering me. They did laser surgery thinking that was it but shortly after laser surgery I found a couple more spots. The interesting thing was the main tumor did not even show up on the PET scan. I think if they had done radiation earlier they would not have gotten it all due to where all the cancer was.
31 at dx 9/06 SCC T4N0M0 with bone invasion upper maxillary Surgery 10/06 CT's clear for 2 years 2nd recurrence - Laser surgery 1/09 dx Tumor board - No surgery to invasive for QOL 35 IMRT 3/30/09 Completed 5/15/09 8 tx Erbitux 3/24/09 Completed 5/6/09 HBO for ORN March & April 2010 Fibula flap 5/10
| | |
Forums23 Topics18,168 Posts196,927 Members13,104 | Most Online458 Jan 16th, 2020 | | | |